Today's Fortune:

  • Tomorrow. ~ Peking Noodle Co.

Not-a-Post

  • Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. Um. Let's see. Multiple intricately rendered, sadistic rape scenes are always sure to turn me against a book.

Do Step in Time

Lucky 7 Links

« The Dol: Fired Up. Ready to Go. | Main | Building a New Tomorrow »

September 03, 2008

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Brilliant.

Once in a while I read a post and think "Wow, wish I'd written that..." -- simply fabulous.

You know, I look at the woman, read about her positions, look at her pregnant daughter and wonder - what the hell can she possibly be thinking? There must be some neuron misfiring in the woman's brain because there's a serious disconnect between her positions and her life.

Nat, thank you.

Diosa, I don't see the disconnect. As far as I'm concerned, Palin's life is a direct result of her positions, which is why I don't share them.

Polly, the disconnect is that I can see what you're saying, but I doubt that Palin can. You'd think the pregnant teenage daughter would be a wake up call that her position is highly ineffective.

I think that Palin's daughter is old enough to have gotten herself some birth control and, failing that, an abortion, without her mother's consent. But I think she'd have been more likely to have done it if she had her mother's support. But clearly, given the fact that her mother got pregnant at 44, despite having just become governor and the high risks associated with a late-in-life pregnancy, implies a certain lack of personal responsibility in the birth control department.

The very idea of "pre-marital" sex raises my hackles, because it assumes that sex is something that is either legitimate or illegitimate and that there is a fundamental difference between sex within a marriage and outside of a marriage, when in reality the primary act is the same, much as flying in an airplane, whether you are married or not, is the same.

Marriage doesn't prevent unwanted pregnancy or disease. Marriage doesn't create financial stability or impart a sense of adult responsibility. But the underlying assumption seems to be that marriage manifests legitimacy and somehow justifies ignoring all sex outside of marriage because it is, by this reasoning, illegitimate.

I am sure Palin feels she has successfully imparted her values to her daughter. She can be proud that her daughters did not have an abortion and will legitimize her "mistake" into an honorable blessing by getting married. But, I have to wonder, what the right thing to do would have been if her daughter had admitted to having sex without being pregnant. Would the families have thought that marriage was the right thing then?

I truly understand why there is no disconnect between what Palin believes and legislates and what is reflected in her family. If marriage, and legitimate sexuality, is defined by a ceremony, rather than personal and mutual responsibility, she's doing a great job as a parent.

I do get what you're saying, but the logic is completely illogical to me. A teenage mother is a teenage mother, marriage or no. I get that Palin doesn't see it that way, but it doesn't make the logic work. In my mind, that logic can only work for the crazy Christians. There's no going back and taking away the sin of premarital sex, there's no denying that abstinence only education doesn't work. There's no way of being hit over the head with that fact harder than your pregnant teenage daughter. But then I suppose you just marry and repent and all is forgiven. That's such bullshit.

you got it. That's it. You explained the system. Only one thing i didn't like. You didn't give me the option of taking the red pill or the blue pill. Can't i just go back to Wonderland?

Diosa, I think that you've hit the nail on the head: it's not about logic, it's about faith. And the thing about arguments based on faith is that they're bound to get circular.

You are so freakin' brilliant. This was a fantastic post. I thank the gods above that I didn't grow up in a family with Palin's values. My mom had no problem trotting me off to the doctor's to get birth control.

The comments to this entry are closed.